Tortuga Caribbean Gourmet Pepper Jelly 5oz Bottles contain a sweet, spicy pepper jelly that adds mild heat and delicious pepper flavor to anything upon which it is spread. Tortuga Caribbean Gourmet Pepper Jelly is made with island spices and West Indian Scotch Bonnet, red, and green peppers, sweetened for a savory treat. Tortuga is a family tradition that has been bringing the taste of the Cayman Islands to North American plates and glasses since 1984. Tortuga products draw on the traditional flavors of the Caribbean.